Will Satoshi's Bitcoin Be Permanently Frozen? New Community Proposal Aims to Freeze 5.6 Million BTC

Will Satoshi's Bitcoin Be Permanently Frozen? New Community Proposal Aims to Freeze 5.6 Million BTC

Prefer freezing 5.6 million dormant BTC rather than letting them fall into the hands of quantum hackers.

The proposal involves approximately 1.7 million BTC in P2PK addresses (including around 1.1 million BTC held by Satoshi, valued at roughly $74 billion), representing about 34% of the entire Bitcoin supply currently exposed to quantum attacks due to publicly revealed public keys. Upon release, the proposal triggered fierce backlash from the community, with critics labeling it a "authoritarian seizure." However, Lopp responded that he would rather freeze 5.6 million dormant BTC than risk their compromise by quantum hackers.

image

Renowned cryptopunk and Casa’s Chief Technology Officer Jameson Lopp, alongside five researchers, submitted a draft titled BIP-361—“Post Quantum Migration and Legacy Signature Sunset”—to GitHub’s bitcoin/bips repository on April 14. The core proposition is straightforward: before quantum computers can break existing cryptographic algorithms, the network should proactively freeze all Bitcoin wallets relying on legacy signature schemes.

According to CoinDesk, Lopp stated in an interview that he does not currently believe immediate implementation is necessary, but emphasized he was engaging in “adversarial thinking about potential future threats.” On X, he further admitted: “I know people don’t like this proposal. I don’t like it either. But I wrote it because I dislike the alternative even more.”

Three-Phase ‘Sunset Plan’: From Restrictions to Freezes

BIP-361 builds upon BIP-360, released in February this year. BIP-360 introduced a new address format called P2MR (pay-to-Merkle-root), similar to existing Taproot addresses but eliminating key path vulnerabilities susceptible to quantum attacks, thereby providing forward security for new coins. BIP-361 aims to address the legacy issue: as of March 1, 2026, over 34% of Bitcoin on-chain has already exposed its public keys—data directly sourced from the BIP-361 document itself.

The proposal outlines three progressive phases:

image

Phase A takes effect approximately three years after activation, at which point sending new BTC to legacy addresses will be prohibited, and all users are expected to have migrated to quantum-resistant address types. Phase B activates five years post-activation, completely deprecating old ECDSA and Schnorr signatures; any Bitcoin remaining in vulnerable addresses will be effectively frozen. Phase C remains incomplete—a proposed mechanism leveraging zero-knowledge proofs (ZKPs) to allow legitimate owners holding mnemonic phrases to reclaim frozen funds.

According to Live Bitcoin News, GitHub reviewer Conduition described Phase C as “the most critical component of any proposal involving confiscatory freezes,” arguing that without such a mechanism, BIP-361 is fundamentally incomplete.

The authors describe the freezing mechanism as a “upgraded private incentive”: lost or frozen coins only slightly increase the value of others’ holdings, whereas recovery via quantum attack would universally devalue all holdings.

5.6 Million Dormant BTC and the $74 Billion Satoshi Holdings

This debate strikes a nerve due to its massive scale.

Lopp estimates that around 5.6 million BTC—28% of the total supply—have not moved in over a decade, with him and other analysts believing these coins are likely lost. At current prices, these dormant tokens are worth approximately $420 billion.

The most symbolic holding is Satoshi’s stash. According to Cointelegraph, approximately 1.7 million BTC are locked in early P2PK addresses, including around 1.1 million BTC attributed to Satoshi, currently valued at roughly $74 billion. These addresses have had their public keys openly exposed on-chain for years. Once quantum computing reaches a critical threshold, attackers could reverse-engineer private keys from public keys using Shor’s algorithm, directly taking control of the funds.

In a CoinDesk interview, Lopp warned that even without mass sell-offs, “any credible evidence suggesting someone can use quantum computers to recover lost or vulnerable coins would immediately trigger widespread market panic.”

On Polymarket, the odds for “Will Satoshi move any Bitcoin by 2026?” stand at around 9.3%, up from 4.5% at the beginning of the year, yet the reaction to BIP-361’s release has been relatively muted, suggesting the market still views it as a governance discussion rather than an urgent catalyst.

Community Backlash Intense: “Stealing Money to Prevent Theft”

BIP-361 touches on Bitcoin’s deepest philosophical tenet: ownership must be unconditional. As soon as the proposal was published, criticism erupted rapidly.

Bitcoin Magazine editor Brian Trollz outright rejected the proposal; TFTC founder Marty Bent called it “absurd”; Metaplanet’s business development lead Phil Geiger sarcastically remarked: “We must steal people’s money to prevent their money from being stolen.”

A comment by X user Cato the Elder went viral: “This quantum proposal is highly authoritarian and confiscatory… There is no rational justification for forcing upgrades and invalidating old spending paths. Upgrades must be 100% voluntary.”

Cysic co-founder and former Algorand quantum-resistant lead Leo Fan added a technical governance perspective: “Ownership becomes conditional. Holding the key no longer guarantees you can spend. This undermines Bitcoin’s promise of an ‘unstoppable currency.’” Yet Fan also acknowledged that removing millions of BTC from circulation could tighten supply and thus drive up coin price.

Discussions on Reddit’s r/cryptocurrency were equally heated (this post received 631 upvotes and 311 comments). The top-rated comment read: “If you fork to freeze wallets in order to hedge investment risk, BTC ceases to be BTC.” Another user took the opposite view: “Let them get hacked, let the price crash for a month. We’ll still buy the dip, just like last time during a survival crisis.”

Source: DeepTide TechFlow

Disclaimer: Contains third-party opinions, does not constitute financial advice

Recommended Reading

Louisiana Seeks Court to Delay Hearing on CFTC's Prediction Market-Related Lawsuit

1 hour ago
Louisiana Seeks Court to Delay Hearing on CFTC's Prediction Market-Related Lawsuit

Nethermind Launches Lightweight Client, Enabling Users to Verify Independently Without Running a Full Node

1 hour ago
Nethermind Launches Lightweight Client, Enabling Users to Verify Independently Without Running a Full Node

Invesco's Stablecoin Reserve Fund Launches on Ethereum and Issues Tokenized Shares

2 hours ago
Invesco's Stablecoin Reserve Fund Launches on Ethereum and Issues Tokenized Shares

Ark Invest increased its holdings in Circle, Coinbase, and Block stocks yesterday, while reducing its position in Bullish stock

2 hours ago
Ark Invest increased its holdings in Circle, Coinbase, and Block stocks yesterday, while reducing its position in Bullish stock

OpenAI CFO: Anthropic's IPO is beneficial for us too, and we are advancing an "unplanned" round of financing

2 hours ago
OpenAI CFO: Anthropic's IPO is beneficial for us too, and we are advancing an "unplanned" round of financing

Italian Court Imposes One-Year Judicial Supervision on Revolut Due to Deficiencies in Anti-Money Laundering Controls

3 hours ago
Italian Court Imposes One-Year Judicial Supervision on Revolut Due to Deficiencies in Anti-Money Laundering Controls

Pump.fun partners with Polymarket to launch in-app prediction market functionality

4 hours ago
Pump.fun partners with Polymarket to launch in-app prediction market functionality